The subtext of the debate surrounding Marin Alsop’s appointment to lead the Baltimore Symphony goes well beyond the orchestra’s internal politics. At the heart of the issue is the groundbreaking nature of the appointment, and the desperate hope on the part of many that Alsop will blaze a trail for future female conductors to follow. But Peter Dobrin suggests that such hopes may be unfair, both to Alsop and those who will come after her. If a new Brahms recording is any indication, the BSO “is getting neither a master nor an incompetent, neither a revelationist nor charlatan. What if Alsop turns out to be – dare we say it – merely a good conductor? Or a very good conductor?”