Kakutani – A Book Critic Who’s Right But Too Judgmental?

Michiko Kakutani is a critical institution. She’s been book critic at the New York Times for 25 years. “Her main weakness is her evaluation fixation. This may seem an odd complaint—the job is called critic, after all—but in fact, whether a work is good or bad is just one of the many things to be said about it, and usually far from the most important or compelling. Kakutani doesn’t offer the stylistic flair, the wit, or the insight one gets from Kael and other first-rate critics; for her, the verdict is the only thing.”